7 Best Replacement for Baking Sheet

Whether you’re a baker or just looking for a new way to get dinner on the table, you’ll need to know the best replacement for baking sheet. Luckily, we’ve already researched and found some great options that will help you cook everything from cookies to casseroles!

Replacement for Baking Sheet

What Is the Best Replacement for Baking Sheet?

Here is the list of 7 best replacements for baking sheets:

  • Cookie Sheet
  • Jelly Roll Pan
  • Pie Plate
  • Cake Pan
  • Casserole Dish
  • Serving Platter
  • Toaster Oven Tray

01. Cookie Sheet

A cookie sheet is a flat, rectangular metal baking sheet with low sides. It can be made from aluminum, stainless steel, or non-stick surfaces. Although it’s technically a “sheet” of metal, it isn’t as thin as you might imagine – rather than being paper-thin like a regular sheet pan and more like the thickness of an aluminum foil pizza box (and therefore pretty sturdy).

Cookie sheets are used for baking cookies, biscuits, and other baked goods. They also have many different uses: roasting vegetables; holding ingredients while prepping meals; holding parchment paper when baking in the oven; keeping food warm while serving buffet style or at parties.

They are also commonly referred to by cooking professionals as “greaseproof pans” since they prevent grease from seeping through them onto the bottom of the oven during the cooking time, which would lead to smoke inhalation if you were using your regular tableware instead!

02. Jelly Roll Pan

A jelly roll pan is a rectangular baking sheet with sides that are 1/2 inch high. They’re great for baking pastry, cookies, and other sweets because they don’t require any parchment paper or aluminum foil to prevent sticking.

Jelly roll pans also make it easier to slide your baked goods off the pan when they’re done. The main downside of using a jelly roll pan is that it doesn’t come in different sizes as standard square baking sheets.

If you want to use multiple batches of cookie dough at once, you may have trouble finding an appropriate-sized area for all your cookies or pastries. You could always buy two jelly roll pans instead!

03. Pie Plate

A pie plate is a round dish with a lip that can be used to bake pies and other desserts. The lip of the pie plate contains the filling, but it is also used for serving purposes. This allows you to keep your hands clean while enjoying your delicious pie!

The best part about using this type of pan is that it’s easy to remove from the oven and serve; however, if you want something more versatile than just being able to bake pies in them, then this may not be your best choice.

04. Cake Pan

A cake pan is a round metal dish with a rough surface for baking cakes. Cake pans are usually made of aluminum or steel and come in different sizes and shapes: square, rectangular, circular, oval, square-shaped with corners cut off at an angle (a “loaf” pan), or shortcrust pans that have no sides at all.

Cakes are baked in these pans so they can rise evenly before being removed from them to cool on wire racks. The texture of the pan’s surface affects how well your cake will turn out—generally, you want something non-sticky so that your batter won’t get stuck to it while baking!

05. Casserole Dish

A casserole dish is an excellent replacement for a baking sheet. It has depth, which makes it suitable for casseroles, but it can also be used for roasting and serving. The deep dish allows air to circulate around the food, so crispy edges on chicken or juicy meat without drying out. You’ll also be able to use it in your oven.

06. Serving Platter

A serving platter is an excellent option if you need to prepare a larger meal or serve many people. They come in all shapes and sizes and can be used for hot and cold foods. Serving platters are also perfect for keeping food warm at the table or serving food when it’s not quite ready yet, making them great multi-taskers!

A serving platter must have enough room for all of your food without being overcrowded. You should also choose one that matches your style to fit well with the rest of your kitchen decor.

07. Toaster Oven Tray

You can put toaster oven trays to use in a variety of ways. They can be used as baking sheets, broiler pans, grilling pans, and even serving dishes. The versatile nature of this product makes it a cost-effective replacement for your traditional baking sheet.

The best thing about these trays is that they are available at most retail stores or online shops at affordable prices. You can buy them in sets of two or four, depending on your needs and how much space you have in your kitchen cabinets and drawers.


We hope we’ve been able to help you find the best replacement for the baking sheet. You can use any of these options in your kitchen today, and they’re all affordable. If you want more information about our picks or anything related to baking sheets, don’t hesitate to contact us!

Similar Posts