Glass Baking Pan or Metal: Which One Is Better for Baking?

It isn’t easy to choose between glass or metal baking pans when you’re in the store looking for one. With so many different brands, shapes, and sizes available, finding which is best for you can be hard. One of the main things that people look at when deciding what pan they want is, how easy it will be to clean after use. 

Glass Vs. Metal Baking Pan

Glass baking pans conduct heat well and distribute it evenly. So your baked goods will come out looking consistent all the way through. Metal baking pans are great for browning food quickly, but they can often result in uneven heating. There is no ideal baking pan, as each material has its benefits and drawbacks. 

If you want to learn more about how to use glass and metal and how they can affect your baking, then keep reading below!

Glass Baking Pan or Metal Which One Is Better for Baking

If you are interested in buying the best bakeware products and accessories for the kitchen, be sure to visit my Recommended Products Page (click to see my page), Which includes all of my top picks by category.

Which Baking Pan Is Perfect for Baking: Glass Vs Metal

In general, metal is better for baking because metal is a more even conductor of heat than glass. In other words, the metal usually gives your food a crispy brown crust with an appealing chewy texture on the inside. While glass tends to produce a soft and doughy crust with less caramelization on its surface.

When it comes to baking, there are a few different options you can choose from for the material of your baking pan. You can use glass or metal. But which one is the best?

Let’s take a look at the comparison of each material:

Glass Baking PanMetal Baking Pan
Cleaning glass baking pans is easy.Metal baking pans are inexpensive and durable.
Glass pans conduct heat slowly, so the edges of a cake or cookie will be smooth and well cooked.They heat up quickly and distribute heat evenly.
Glass baking pans are expensive.Metal pans take up too much room in the dishwasher.
It can be difficult to maneuver glass pans because they can be heavy. The metal pans are too hot to touch after they have been in the oven.
If dropped or mishandled, they can break. 

What Is the Difference Between a Baking Pan and a Baking Dish?

A baking pan is typically a rectangular sheet of metal with relatively shallow sides. A baking dish is a more rounded, oval, or rectangular-shaped container made from either metal or glass, with deeper sides.

Read Also: Can You Use Metal Baking Pans in the Dishwasher?

Can You Use a Baking Pan Instead of a Baking Dish?

You can use a baking pan as a baking dish. A baking dish is typically cooked at a higher temperature or needs more depth than what a baking pan can provide. For example, casseroles are often cooked in a baking dish. Because they need to be cooked at a higher temperature than what is typically allowed in a baking pan. 

Check out this top-rated glass baking pan on Amazon here.

Can You Use an Aluminum Tray Instead of a Baking Pan?

You can use an aluminum tray instead of a baking pan. Just be sure to line the aluminum tray with foil or parchment paper to prevent the food from sticking. Aluminum is a conductor of heat, and it will cook your food more quickly.

If you don’t have access to a cookie sheet, you use a baking pan, but they are not preferable. Because cookie sheets are typically thicker than baking pans, they cook food more evenly and help protect it from sticking to the pan. Baking pans can scratch easily if you’re careless while using them. 

Check out this top-rated metal baking pan on Amazon here.

How Do You Get Black Off Baking Pans?

There are a few ways to get the black or burnt residue off baking pans. You can use a scrub pad, steel wool, or vinegar.

Method 1:

If the residue is stuck on tight, you can heat the pan until it’s hot and then pour vinegar on it. The acid in the vinegar will help to break down the burnt food. Let the vinegar sit on the pan for a few minutes, and then scrub it off with a scrub pad or steel wool.

Method 2: 

You can also try using oven cleaner. Just spray it on the pan and let it sit for a few minutes. Then scrub it off with a scrub pad or steel wool.

Method 3:

Try using baking soda and water paste. Make a thick paste with baking soda and water, then spread it on the pan. Let it sit for a few minutes, and then scrub it off.

How Do You Make a Baking Pan Look New Again?

There are a few ways to make a baking pan look new again. You can try any method to make your backing pan look new. 

  • One is to scrub it with a steel wool pad and then rinse it with hot water. 
  • Fill the pan with 1-2 inches of ammonia and let it sit for 24 hours. After that, scrub the pan with a stiff brush and rinse it with hot water.
  • Use a metal polish, such as Brasso.
  • Use a baking soda paste. To make the baking soda paste, mix 1/4 cup of baking soda with 1/4 cup of water. Rub the paste onto the pan with a soft cloth, then rinse and dry the pan.

Pro Tip: After using any of these methods, wash your hands thoroughly after cleaning the pan.


It is generally accepted that glass baking pans work better for cooking, and metal works best for browning. Therefore, which baking pan is perfect depends on what you want to accomplish with your dish. Ultimately, this decision comes down to personal preference. Try both out and see how they affect your dishes.

If you are interested in the top-rated bakeware products and accessories, be sure to visit my Recommended Products Page (click to see my page) Which includes all of my top picks by category.

Similar Posts